Showing posts with label gay infiltrate Orthodox Judaism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label gay infiltrate Orthodox Judaism. Show all posts

Thursday, August 27, 2015

Study Shows 42% Of "Orthodox" Don't Think Homosexuality Should Be Discouraged RL!

'13 Study on opposition of homosexuality
42% Of "Orthodox" (includes those not in these 2 categories) Don't Think Homosexuality Should Be Discouraged!
30% of "Haradim" don't think that homosexuality should be discouraged
62% of Modern "Orthodox" don't think that homosexuality should be discouraged

remember this study is a few years old and unfortunately the numbers probably are much worse today


Rabbis, Teachers, Askonim, and Leaders etc. are responsible for this problem, It's long past the time we spoke out strongly against homosexuality.

How many times have you ever heard a teshuva drasha against accepting homosexuality, and voting against pro homosexuality political candidates?

Wednesday, August 5, 2015

Ami Magazine Editor "Masers" on Rabbi To District Attorney Because He Opposed Ami's Stance On Same Sex "Marriage"



Last night Yitzchok Frankfurter (Ami's editor) admitted on the Just Enough Heshy radio show that he reported a specific Rabbi in Lakewood to the District Attorney's office for threatening him. 

After a thorough investigation, the only correspondence that the Rabbi had with Ami Magazine was the following email.  That email contained the "threat" to Frankfurter.  

The only "threat" was that he will show his editorial to key rabbis in Lakewood, (which can be seen in the following letter).  

After Mr. Frankfurter admitted to massering on the Lakewood Rabbi, Mr. Frankfurter had the gall to say in an attempt to paint us as terrorists (read the comments clearly written by Ami to our first editorial) "You know what the problem I was actually trying to prevent him from getting involved in craziness, cause I see we're he's leading, these guys are going totally off".  

Then he has the complete hypocrisy to defend himself by saying about our accusations that "those types of accusations our the worst"  (This got cut off on the tape but can be seen at the tail end of the video on the bottom)





"Threatening" letter


"Rabbi" Yitzchok Frankfurter please answer us a few questions?  (we now know you read this blog)
What is the heter to masser on a Jew for following the Torah?
Is going to rabbis with your own editorial a real threat?
Did you go to a rabbi to get a heter to go to the DA?
If so which Rabbi?
Did you show them the "threatening letter"?
Can I also go to the directly to the DA when someone is molesting a child?
How about the police?
Will you devote a editorial to hilchos mesira showing your heter to go to the DA?



In response to Ami's critique we changed the name of our original anti-Ami editorial from

"Ami Magazine "Paskens" It's A Chiyuv To Support Same Sex "Marriage""

 to 
"Ami Magazine "Paskens" It's Assur To Oppose Same Sex "Marriage""


The worst part about Ami is they are like a chazer they pretend to be kosher by saying they are against same sex "marriage", but then they clarify it with treyfus (I forgot, I was supposed to be literal) make that, the ability to regurgitate, by saying things like it's assur to fight against it, and we shouldn't be upset because we lost nothing.

Remember, subscribers and advertisers will force Ami Magazine to stop its perversion!



Will Be'ezras Hashem put up editorial on whole interview tomorrow

Wednesday, April 29, 2015

Flatbush Jewish Journal Reporter, Continues By Pushing Same Sex "Marriage"



David Rosenberg Retweeted this tweet showing he supports same sex "marriage"


This follows a tweet earlier this week were he publicly stated he's "pro gay"




Everybody should Email the Flatbush Jewish Journal at editor@thefjj.com demanding they fire pro same sex "marriage" reporter David J Rosenberg



Sunday, April 26, 2015

Flatbush Jewish Journal's Star Reporter Admits He's "Pro Gay"

Rosenberg's pro gay tweet


David Rosenberg is a political columnist for the Flatbush Jewish Journal (FJJ), his admission to being pro gay makes us wonder a few things:
1. How much has Rosenberg's pro gay ideology influenced his articles and thus the public?
2. Did FJJ Owner Mordy Mehlman know his stance before he was hired?
3. If he didn't, why not? Shouldn't he have asked him in today's political climate about his opinion on homosexuality before letting him writing a political column that can influence thousands of voters?
4. Is it possible Mordy Mehlman is also pro gay?
and more importantly now that they know what Rosenberg is:

5. Will they immediately fire Rosenberg?
6. Will they make changes to insure that they will not ever have a pro homosexual paper, but one that follows the Torah and opposes toevah even over promises of money?

Tuesday, November 11, 2014

Poll Shows Majority Of People In The UK Think Yeshivas Should Be Forced To Teach Homosexuality

We have asked you whether LGBT rights should also be included in faith schools' curriculum and you said: YES.
More than 50% of the people who took the poll said they would like to see gay rights taught at parochial schools  (yeshivas).
Over 36% said they wouldn't like to have their children discussing the topic at school whereas 12% said that it would depend on how the subject would be taught.
The poll was set after theEducation Ministry said that faith schools will not be forced to include LGBT rights in their curriculum. after they sent in Government Inspectors Teach Jewish Girls About Same Sex "Marriage" In Orthodox Girls Schools.

A reader has reacted to the poll on our Facebook page.
Joanne Jones said: "We all need to be tolerant of each other no matter what our sexual preferences, culture or religion. Thought that was a normal way of thinking in 2014 for the UK?"
(canterburytimes) highlight our additions

Thursday, February 20, 2014

"Orthodox" Jewish Woman To Celebrate Her Daughter's Same Gender "Wedding"

THIS IS THE RESULT OF 40 YEARS OF JEWISH APATHY TOWARDS HOMOSEXUALITY, AND THE HOMOSEXUAL AGENDA

Don’t Exclude Our Gay, "Orthodox" Children

February 19, 2014 By:
Sunnie EpsteinYMS

As a Modern "Orthodox" Jew and a Jewish educator, I have written, spoken and taught about homosexuality and our need as a community to address this issue within the framework of halacha it's simple it's assur, or Jewish law, for many years. I had already been an advocate for the LGBTQ community for decades when our daughter Rachie, one of our four children, came out more than four years ago I wonder if there is a connection here, where were the rabbis condeming a "orthodox" jew advocating for LGBTQ?.

Why? Because I feel that as religious Jews, we have a moral imperative to ensure that all members of our community are safe, valued and healthy. We are taught to use the midah of compassion here, as we do for so many other issues.   compassion doesn't mean throwing out the Torah in the garbage

When Rachie was 22 years old, she called me and my husband, and in the course of our conversation, basically said, “Mom, I am seeing someone I really care about, and this person is a woman. I am gay.” Neither of us were surprised. I asked her if she was happy and if this was a true expression of her core personality. My husband, Ken, just reminded her to stay safe and not do anything dangerous.

As an "educated" person, I am certain that biology and “how we are wired” is just the way G-d makes us educated means being able to back this preposterous notion with facts and figures. Furthermore, I am aware that 10 to 15 percent of any community is on the gay spectrum, and there is no exemption from this reality in the religious Jewish community since the 10 percent number which originated from Kinsey you should remember even he acknowledged that Orthodox Jews had much less homosexuality then everyone else.

My husband and I firmly believe that as shomrei mitzvot, or Torah-observant, Jews, we have an obligation to accept, protect and value all human beings who are created in the image of G-d, betzelem elokim which has nothing to do with homosexuality. G-d makes us as G-d chooses and we are not to stand in judgment nor are we to exclude those that G-d creates, for every human being is designed by G-d, and to allow any such exclusion is to directly insult G-d as well as the person excluded . Halacha teaches us this. does this also apply to pedophiles, burglars, rapists, murderers?

Of course, many in our community and extended family do not see it this way. Rachie has not been able to see herself associated with anything “Orthodox,” though she is observant except publicly violating in a lehachis manner for a issur deoryas that carries a punishment of malkos mardus and engaged Jewishly in profound and meaningful ways.

However, this has changed recently, due to her involvement in ESHEL, the "Orthodox" LGBTQ community that is named for the tent into which Avraham and Sarah invited all who came by. Rachie —and the rest of us — now has a home for her religiously "observant", gay self. more like nimrod

I am deeply saddened by any community that judges and pushes our daughter away. Any community that does not fully embrace and value Rachie is the one that loses, for she is a gifted young lady and an "observant" and knowledgeable Jew. I often la­ment how our observant communities are sending away some of our exceptional people who could contrib­ute so much and would — if only they were embraced and valued instead of judged and excluded. she wants us to embrace homosexuals or homosexuality lets continue reading to find out.

Now that Rachie is committed to spending her life with her beloved Liz, our main challenge is how we as a family navigate our "Orthodox" community. We are making some decisions that are seen as compromises to some but allow us to more successfully achieve our goal.

For example, in planning a Shabbat "Kiddush" for the "couple", we will do this at our home with friends and community members, rather than at our synagogue, to ensure that those present want to be part of the celebration. We will plan their "wedding" with the same approach, knowing that some relatives and friends will not attend.  "kiddush", "wedding" by "orthodox" jews to celebrate homosexuality see the problem yet?

As time goes on and we come to terms with the reality of all members of our observant world, our hope is that more of our community will learn to see and accept and value each of our children for who they are and the sexuality they were "born" with.  she wants us to value not just the homosexual but homosexuality!

Sunnie Epstein and her family are active members of ESHEL, which is planning a Parent Retreat March 7-9 at Capital Camps in Waynesboro, Pa. Contact the author at: shulisrose@ aol.com or Miryam Kabakov at: miryam@eshelonline.org.
(Jewishexponent) highlights my comments


If your wondering how we got to a point that someone can claim to be Orthodox and write this trash
THIS IS WHAT HAPPENS WHEN MOST OF OUR RABBANIM (FROM ALL CIRCLES) NEVER SPEAK UP AGAINST THIS EVIL, AND WE VOTE FOR POLITICIANS WHO CAUSE THIS TO BE COME MAINSTREAM
JERRY NADLER, HELENE WEINSTEIN, RHODA JACOBS, JOSEPH LENTOL, ELLEN JAFFE ETC.  

EVEN THE FEW OF US WHO WOULDN'T VOTE FOR THOSE, AS BAD, AS I JUST LISTED STILL VOTE FOR POLITICIANS LIKE

EVEN THE BEST OF OUR POLITICIANS LIKE DOV HIKIND AND CHAIM DEUTSCH HAVE TERRIBLE RECORDS ON THIS ISSUE THAT SHOULD MAKE THE ENTIRE JEWISH COMMUNITY ASHAMED, AND EMBARRASSED

Tuesday, January 7, 2014

How Gay Propaganda Infiltrated Maimonides High School Founded By Rav Yoshe Ber


Boston’s renowned Maimonides School was established by Rav Soloveitchik in 1937, and it maintains a reputation for providing some of the most advanced learning Jewish day schools can offer. This past fall, it offered a variety of history courses to the senior class, including AP Government, Art History, and, amongst others, a Minorities in America course. The course material covered a wide range of issues and addressed the minority experience of African Americans, Asian Americans, and others. The gay community was addressed as a sample unit on sexual minorities, and parents began to complain. Snide jokes were made, parentally-authored emailed were sent, and enough complaints were made that the teacher brought the unit to a shuddering halt and discontinued the homosexuality unit entirely. while it was removed, the parents were right to fight against this, and it may have been an oversight by the administration who originally allowed it who may have not known what was in the curriculum, the fact that this can happen show us how dangerous this movement is When a "teaching moment" was at the fingertips of this institution, it chose passivity and ignorance.

At Yeshiva University, there is limited discussion of this topic. While other institutions have GSAs (Gay-Straight Alliances), notice that this low-life wants a Gay-Straight Alliance in a yeshiva and the nation as a whole engages in a forward-marching process to address the existence of a long-ignored yet prominent population of its citizens, the religious community has remained "tragically" silent by comparison. While there are internet forums and small-scale organizations like "Ortho"dykes in New York and בית הפתוחה in Jerusalem, the gay "Orthodox" experience is a conundrum from which the religious community has largely disengaged.

While non-Orthodox Jewish groups might "might" I don't think this extra word was unintentional compromise halakha – Jewish law – in the name of "progress", they have nevertheless done the powerful job of choosing to acknowledge the existence of sexual minorities and grappling with a strong and antiquated "heterosexist culture of the West" whose "impositions" on the lives of "all" have been greatly troubling. One organization, Mayyim Hayyim Living Waters Community Mikveh, located in Newton, Massachusetts, has chosen to grapple with the seeming contradiction of Leviticus 18:22’s prohibition of male homosexual activity ("rabbinically" it's really assur m'dorysa learned out from "maase eretz mitrzrayim" expanded to include that of female homosexual activity) by "sanctifying" sexual identity. In addition to the more traditional occasions of menstrual purity and conversion, they have "expanded" their use of the mikveh, Jewish ritual bath. Accounts have been given of people thus employing the use of this Jewish practice to commemorate sexual transitions, including sexual reassignment surgeries, "coming out" ceremonies, and other related occasions. or in Mayyim Hayyims own words "Coming out as gay, lesbian, bisexual or transgender"

The United States is also currently engaged in a nationwide debate over the legalization of gay "marriage" and the "acceptability" of transgender culture in school settings. The Mathis family is currently one such example of society’s grappling to make space for transgender children in a school setting, spurring debates on the gender binary’s place, or lack thereof, in the bathroom setting in other words allowing a boy in the girls bathroom. Certain universities, in a similar direction, have chosen to provide “male-identified” and “female-identified” as well as “neutral” assignations to their restrooms, something I believe should be nationally adopted as mandated policy 3 bathrooms, and still boy allowed in girls bathrooms. The heterosexual fallacy, so often and so fortunately broken down in college environments, still holds strong in many religious frameworks, including the staple Modern Orthodox institution of higher education, Yeshiva University. There is no LGBTQA society on campus and this mamzeres wants to change that?, nor is homosexuality a topic often discussed in the classroom. Additionally, the separate sex education has contributed to an increase of women-specific classes such as “Women in Jewish Law” and “Women in the Bible,” which is a wonderful stride toward liberalism by a 1950’s standard, but a retrograde move in light of contemporary civilization. Most universities include a Gender and Sexuality department, and yet this university offers only a Women’s Studies department so she wants YU to promote what the torah hates?. The omission of entire fields of pseudointellectualism and of sexuality is a blatant refusal to acknowledge reality or endorse evil practices. It is juvenile to deny Kinsey experiments Kinsey wrote this about homosexuality in the Orthodox Jewish Community "that the Homosexual among Orthodox Jewish groups appears to be phenomenally low", sexual variety, and gender ambiguity. I would hope the Jewish people would champion the concept of nuance and struggle in order to do the grandest kavod habriyot, respect for one’s fellow creatures, and acknowledge their existence of course we should acknowledge their existence you can't fight a war with out acknowledging that your enemy exists.
The current age is a distinctly exciting time of progression and national debate. Globalization and technological advancements have contributed to an ongoing discussion which engages in discovering more about sexuality and which facilitates the maximum standards of inclusivity for minorities. As Jews, we must know better than perhaps any other collectively-identified group in world history that silence is denial. May we be, in the words of King Lear, only “more sinned against than sinning,” and never, God forbid, the reverse.


(thebeaconmag)  The beacon was formally a paper linked up with YU but has since left them, they now advertise for Chovevi Torah on their website, Rachel Renz went to Maimonides and is currently in Stern, she signed a petition against the OU and Young Israel for protesting against same gender "marriage"


Monday, December 23, 2013

A Modern Guide To Kashrus; How to Shect A Pig?

This story happened a few years ago


Being "Frum" and Gay
This weekend, the "Orthodox" Community at Penn (OCP) and JQYouth (JQY), a group that provides support to LGBT "Orthodox" Jews collaborated to develop a shabbaton aimed at addressing issues that gay and lesbian Jews face within the "Orthodox" community. The shabbaton built upon the format and ideas originally presented at the “Being Gay in the Orthodox World” panel that was held at Yeshiva University over all the Rosh Yeshivas objections this December.


After morning services, "Rabbi" Friedman held a brief survey of contemporary literature on homosexuality. Taking a "neutral" stance on the issue, "Rabbi" Friedman reviewed responses spanning from Rav Moshe Feinstein’s t’shuvah (response) stating that homosexuality reflects a deliberate act of rebellion against God, to contemporary approaches of "Rabbi" Chaim Rapoport and "Rav" Yuval Sherlo, that go so far as to deal with questions such as whether lesbian couples should wear hair coverings and observe laws of ritual purity.

The events of the weekend were widely considered a success drawing many people from diverse communities on campus. The event, according to one of the organizers, Isaac Setton, was a "kiddush hashem" as many people from many different backgrounds saw the "Orthodox" community coming together in support of the LGBT community. The "Orthodox" Community at Penn was able to organize and facilitate many discussions about the future of "Orthodoxy" and "Orthodox" education. One participant remarked, “One day, the people being educated at this event will sit on the board of shuls and schools and it will be up to them to make sure that when this issue comes up it is not a shock and is dealt with properly.” The people who attended the event were all glad they were provided with the opportunity to engage with this issue.
(From a "orthodox" lesbian website) highlights are additions they forgot to say

Tuesday, September 24, 2013

See How Societies Acceptance Of Homosexuality Effected Even The Most Insular Chasdish Woman!


Library Book that helped convince a "Chasidish" woman she was a lesbian


GAY AND MARRIED FOR 25 YEARS 
 It's true. I have ten children and I've been married for twenty-five years. I went to the most chassidish schools. I got married when I was sixteen. Growing up, we spoke Yiddish. My children and my grandchildren all speak Yiddish. Just from looking, maybe you couldn't tell that I am gay. I would be invisible, and not just because of the way I dress or because of any of those things. I would be invisible because I am not out to almost anyone. I look like all the other bubbies and mommies on my block.

It's just too scary for me. I am afraid. I have too much to lose.

I am terrified that someone might hear me talking on my phone one day, or somehow, just from looking into my eyes, know what I am thinking.

I went to a library, not one near my house, but in the city. It's not allowed to read goyishe books. I said I was going to the women's doctor. The office is right nearby. I sat all the way in the back of the library, down low, between the shelves, and I had there a little pile of books about being gay. I put my purse on top of the books, so if someone went past, they wouldn't see. In the bathroom, I changed the way I cover my hair, so no one would see me and know what kind of person I am, where I live, who my Rebbe is, and tell on me.

When I opened the first book the librarian gave me, there was a photograph of something I had never seen before.* I didn't even know how to look at the picture. I couldn't understand it. I read the words and I didn't understand those either. I felt like I was stupid. I felt like I lived in a foreign country. I began to sweat with terrible fear and I looked all around me but no one was there. No one was looking. But I thought someone was looking, so I got up and I went to the bathroom and I hid in the stall for maybe a half hour. I felt like the worst kind of pervert. I think I cried. I did cry.

When I went back to the place I had been sitting, the librarian had already put the books away. I thought that G-d was making it harder for me to do a sin. He was giving me a chance to change my mind. So I thought about it and decided that I would only take one book to look at, not a pile. But then I thought about the pictures in the book. Even the cover made my face burn.

If someone saw me there, without even reading books like that, I could have lost my kids. I could have been kicked out of my community. My mother and father would have sat shiva. They still might sit shiva. I still might be kicked out of the community. I still might lose my kids. Why am I doing this interview? It's dangerous. I should stop. But once you open your mouth, it's hard to close it again.

When we were first married, I had to go to Manhattan, to bring a document to where my husband worked, and he didn't want me to be seen by the other men there, so he came outside. There were two women there, in the doorway, touching each other, kissing, and I looked away but looked back again. I couldn't help it. My man said not to look because they are gay. I didn't know what that meant. But it made me feel funny inside myself. I wanted to do what they were doing, I wanted to be them. They looked happy. But I thought it was probably a bad thing, a goyishe thing. But still, I said to my husband,  "I think I am like those people."I didn't know anything about gay at all. It bothered my husband. He said something about looking at dogs when they are doing things, that it makes your children like dogs too. Even when he walks in the street, he doesn't look up. He doesn't look at me, or anyone else either.

I don't even know, for sure, if I am gay. I think I am, but I've never been with a woman. But I like women, I feel more comfortable with women, and I don't know so many men. My father is a good man. He is a refined man. He makes the cholent for my mother before shabbos and he bakes the challah too. He's never raised a hand to us. He wouldn't hurt anybody. But everything he does, he asks a sha'alah. He wouldn't be happy if I ever came out. He would die.

My mother is from Europe. She sits and peels vegetables and says tehillim from memory all day long. She doesn't have fancy jewelry or anything fancy at all in the house. She raised me to be like her, not to be any other way. When she lights the shabbos licht, she prays that all her children and grandchildren and great-grandchildren are yirei shomayim. And what would she think, if I told her I am gay? I'm not even sure my mother knows what gay is. I can't imagine explaining it to her. We don't ever talk about those kind of things. I might kill my own father and mother, chas vecholilah, if I said I am gay.

So why say anything? Why do anything at all? I am already not so young. When I was younger, a girl, I felt like I was connected to many other girls and I could talk and I could be myself with them, relaxed and...I don't know how to explain it. It wasn't such a big thing, a touch, a word.  I didn't know I wouldn't feel so friendly when I got married. I thought getting married, it's supposed to be even better. But for me, even though my husband is a good man, a holy Jew and a baal chesed, it isn't better. He says it's not right for men and women to be close. My husband doesn't use my name. He calls me "di mame" in front of the children and nothing at all in private. It's not very Jewish of me, but I sometimes think I'd like someone to love me and touch me, just because. It's so lonely.
(* The book was The Whole Lesbian Sex Book)
(from a "orthodox" toeavah website)

If not for the fact that society accepted toevah she never would have had these problems!  Every single person who voted for toevah candidates has a chelek in this and the thousands of other peoples averas!

please show this article to rabbi David Niederman, and his Aroni counterparts (also for Skvere and Kiryas Joel) .

please also show this article to as many Rabbaniem, Poskiem, Roshei Yeshivas, Rebbes etc. , and even some half way decent askaniem  as possible!

Thursday, August 22, 2013

"Orthodox" Jews Cheer An "Orthodox" Jew Who "Came Out" As "Gay"

shutterstock_104759546
Still Think Toevah Doesn't Effect Us


This March, history was quietly made in a Saturday morning "Orthodox" minyan (prayer quorum) at Brandeis University. Avi, a 22-year-old then-college junior from the Boston area, was called up to the Torah for an "aliyah". While nothing was said outright, and he had been chosen for no particular reason, the unintentional message was clear: complete acceptance.eicha heysa kezonah, maybe we should give out aliyas to jews who decide to become michelel shabbos 

Two days before his aliyah, Avi (some names, including this one, have been altered for confidentiality) tacitly confirmed his sexuality in front of a weekly Jewish learning group for the Brandeis "Orthodox" Organization (BOO) known as Mishmar. For Avi, "coming out" was “a whole process,” that began with informing “a few close friends” during his sophomore year. Avi then told his family, who, despite being shocked, were “wonderful about it.”

Avi told friends who knew he was gay to let the rumor about his homosexuality spread through the community a few days before his speech in order to ensure a large attendance, and then spoke about the "importance" of accepting gay members of the Jewish community. this is the danger of this movement, If we are strong in this movement especially during election this tragedy never would have happenend After implicitly revealing his "true" sexual identity, Avi says, “[his speech] was well received, a lot of people came up to me and thanked me to make a rasha in to a tdadik is the worst avera possible, said it was long overdue.” News of his sexuality “spread through the Jewish world in a cool way.” On a trip to Israel, Avi was congratulated by a stranger who had heard of his coming out.

The conversation and attitudes around the acceptance of lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT) Jews are not well-defined in Modern Orthodox Jewish society, though being gay may not carry as much of a stigma as one would think. According to Avi, most of the hesitation in the Jewish community is due to the tone of the conversations surrounding the topic. Avi feels that “growing up through the day school and yeshiva gap year system, I only heard about homosexuality in pejorative contexts. That conversation needs to change, and we must deal with this head-on.” and if we don't start fighting they will win with most formally Orthodox Jews.  every single Jew who supports pro toevah politicians is directly responsible for this mess!

The conversation largely started in 2001 with the release of Trembling Before G-d, Sandi Simcha Dubowski’s documentary detailing the hardships of being an ""observant but gay Jew. Other notable contributions to the discussion included Wrestling with God and Men: Homosexuality in the Jewish Tradition, the 2004 book by "Rabbi" Steven Greenberg, the first openly gay "Orthodox" rabbi, and the 2011 Declaration on the "Torah" Approach to Homosexuality, a document written by a group of 25 rabbis, mental health professionals and people who claim to have overcome their sexuality, and which rejects any integration of Torah observance and homosexuality. Where is our statement of principles against this? Even the torah deceleration cowed away from dealing with the chiyuv gamur to ostracize all members of the "toevah community". The "toevah community" means here those who identify themselves by their assur lifestyle, not those who are over on mishkav zachar who don't identify themselves by such behavior(or worse "proudly" identify themselves).  The later we have to miakrev, the Former are hopless because they turned an averah in to a mitzva! We (from Satmar to YU) should have put all those who advocate for "orthodox" acceptance of mishkav zachar itself in cherem (not just those who practice it) this especially includes the leaders of all "Jewish" toevah groups!

In 2010, a group of "Orthodox" rabbis and educators met to face the rising issue of LGBT Jews directly. They convened and published The Statement of Principles, an official statement as to where these rabbis stand on the LGBT movement and Judaism. The Statement contains the signatures of more than 200 "rabbis" and Jewish leaders, both male and female. many if not most of the "rabbis" are chovevei torah types One prominent name featured on the list is "Rabbi" Dr. Haskel Lookstein of the New York City-based Congregation Kehilath Jeshurun (KJ) and the Jewish school Ramaz. his grandfather the Ramaz is rolling over in his grave

Lookstein says that his community is “non-judgmental,” and though he cannot speak for all of KJ, his institution’s stance is that:

“Homosexual sex is a serious sin, but is completely separate from the acceptance of a homosexual person as a Jew and as a human being, who merits respect, love, welcome and encouragement to be part of the community.”If a person identifies themselves by a forbidden behavior they are classified as a min. 

This concurs with The Statement of Principles, which states that:

“All human beings are created in the image of God and deserve to be treated with dignity and respect (kevod haberiyot). Every Jew is obligated to fulfill the entire range of mitzvoth between person and person in relation to persons who are homosexual or have feelings of same sex attraction. Embarrassing, harassing or demeaning someone with a homosexual orientation or same-sex attraction is a violation of Torah prohibitions that embody the deepest values of Judaism.” the Torah agrees with this statement provided  those people are trying to keep the Torah but sometimes fail,  Unfortunately due to the current moral climate in the world today most people who have the desire for mishkav zachar today want to change the torah!

To Lookstein and his community, someone who is gay is like someone who does not fully uphold the laws of Shabbat or kashrut. Lookstein assures that he would not throw out someone who did not follow those rules from his community, and believes the same should be applied to LGBT Jews. He says that in some ways he has “greater empathy” for those who are gay than for those who break Shabbat, because for the former group, it is not a choice. And DR Lookstein also can't understand that by a person identifying themselves by their forbidden sexual behavior they are now transformed into a mumer lehachis.

The "observant" Jewish LGBT organization Eshel, founded in 2010 and based in New York City, does not believe that the Statement is a finished product, but, rather, a “great first step,”the last step involves spitting on the Torah or Worse according to Miryam Kabakov, Eshel’s director and co-founder. Eshel hosts retreats, weekends, speakers, education initiatives and support groups for family members of out Jews who want to learn more about guiding their loved one and themselves through the challenges ahead. Kabakov is inspired by the newest crop of Modern Orthodox leaders, and believes that there is a good chance for them to become even more accepting than the current ones due to the fact that there are “so many positive images of gay people in media now, in TV and in the news—as long as Orthodox communities are there with the world, they will have a better chance of being more accepting.”and the more we help those rishaiempush toevah the worse this problem will get.

For Kabakov, the most difficult part about being an LGBT Jew in the Modern "Orthodox" world is the feeling of “knowing that you can’t go back to place you grew up in. There are very few places I feel comfortable in an Orthodox shul. Going back there you have to hide who you are, who you want, what they want, but [they] look at you like you have a disease or something’s wrong with you.” Despite these feelings of alienation, Kabakov says that she started Eshel to try and reconcile her sexuality and her Jewish background, which she enjoyed and considers it to be the “greatest gift my parents gave me.” For Kabakov, Eshel is the one place she can feel these two separate entities of hers are “in sync,” and uses the organization to reach out to other "observant" Jews who are gay or are questioning their sexuality.

Although the Brandeis community immediately embraced Avi and his homosexuality, members of his home synagogue were not as quick to accept. According to Avi, “it’s a generational thing,”we don't even know how destorctive this movement and the effects of it's laws will be on our children and he received lots of stares and some cold receptions from various adult and rabbinical figures both in and out of his community.

Recently, a rabbi from Avi’s home shul gave a Saturday morning sermon condemning the Boy Scouts of America for accepting gay members, and giving into public pressure why can't the Moetzes or a "rebbes" come out with a simaler statement. This speech was given shortly after Avi’s coming-out, and on a Shabbat when Avi was in attendance at the shul. Despite moments like these, many members of Avi’s community have come to support him and his sexual orientation.

Even Jews who consider themselves to be from “the more "observant" end of the spectrum” are altering their attitudes on frum (observant) LGBT Jews. JL, an Orthodox young adult from the New York area, says he would accept an LGBT Jew as part of the community if he or she “realizes it’s not an ideal situation and takes appropriate steps.” For JL and other members of his community, it’s not about whether they are gay, it’s about how gay Jews display their sexuality. JL is stringent in observing commandments and tradition, taking on more than most Jews, such as wearing a black hat and kippah the fact that they can think a person is more observant based on a yamulka shows we have another serious problem, besides mishkav zachar, and eating only strictly kosher food. JL and his compatriots view being gay as akin to being “an alcoholic” or an “adulterer,” an alcoholic” or an “adulterer doesn't publicly identify themselves as a member of those communities.  Also an alcoholic not chayuv misah and believe that there should be attempts to “reform” their homosexuality in the same way that an adulterer or alcoholic would seek help and try to make amends for their behavior. Despite the disconnect between chosen and not-chosen behavior, JL’s ideas are niche in that in some ways they are still accepting, but still have far to go to be considered within the secular American mainstream.

Some rabbis and Jewish communities are not as "tolerant" as Lookstein and Eshel. Rabbi Steven Pruzansky, of the popular Congregation Bnai Yeshurun in Teaneck, New Jersey, keeps a prolific blog, infamous for the anti-Obama post “The Decline and Fall of the American Empire.” Though he declined to comment for this article, his statements on gay rights are littered throughout the website. On his blog, Pruzansky questions the moral and societal implications of legalizing gay marriage, wondering if it will lead to “polygamy? Polyandry? Polyamory? Poly-want-a-crackery?” Rabbi Pruzansky cites Talmudic and other textual sources for his views.

In another blog post on the topic, from last December, Pruzansky attacked "Rabbi" Akiva Herzfeld of "chovevei torah" Portland, Maine, an "Orthodox" rabbi who came out in support of gay "marriage", stating that Rabbi Herzfeld “renounced (your) heritage, abandoned the Torah, and embraced the political correctness of the age – just as the Hellenist Jews did in ancient times.” Essentially, Pruzansky told Herzfeld that he’s no longer a Orthodox Jew due to his stance on LGBT members in society. From these writings, it appears unlikely that Rabbi Pruzansky would accommodate an LGBT member in his synagogue that is a mumer lichachis.
 
Some Orthodox rabbis have suggested that their gay congregants undergo reparative therapy. Reparative (also known as conversion) therapy is dangerous according to homosexuals because it implies that there is something wrong with homosexuality. According to statistics from the Human Rights Campaign (a gay rights advocacy organization), based on a study conducted by San Francisco State University most studies are predetermined by who foots the bill, those who undergo reparative therapy have increased risks of suicide, depression, sexually transmitted infections and narcotics abuse. The American Medical Association (AMA) “opposes the use of ‘reparative’ or ‘conversion’ therapy that is based upon the assumption that homosexuality per se is a mental disorder or based upon the a priori assumption that the patient should change his/her homosexual orientation.” Other organizations, such as the American Psychiatric Association (APA), have also voiced their concerns over conversion therapy and its damaging effects on its victims. The use of the practice on minors was banned in the state of California in 2012.


Why The APA Says repetitive Therapy is harmful

Although the practice of conversion therapy has come under attack, Arthur Goldberg, co-director and co-founder of the organization Jews Offering New Alternatives to Healing (JONAH), a group specializing in reparative therapy, maintains their position on the process. According to Goldberg, numerous studies have been conducted that “clearly indicate that change [of sexual orientation] is possible” through therapy. Goldberg contends that the therapy methods that JONAH supports see the sexuality as just a “by-product,” and seek to treat what they see as the individual’s issues with “self-esteem and self-worth,” as they believe these are the true underlying issues. Goldberg stated that “the jury is out” on the position of the APA and AMA; furthermore, the JONAH website cites Dr. Robert Spitzer’s study on the effects of reparative therapy for its main defenses of the practice. In 2001, Spitzer conducted a study entitled “Can Some Gay Men and Lesbians Change Their Sexual Orientation?” and concluded that it was possible, despite numerous controversies surrounding the study and the manner in which it was conducted. A little more than a year ago, Spitzer retracted his findings and admitted that he was “wrong” about the conclusions he drew from the data and about the study in general. Goldberg maintains that Spitzer “didn’t retract his claims; he apologized for any harm he may have caused.” Despite Goldberg’s beliefs, there are rabbis who have changed their views on reparative therapy. Rabbi Fred Nebel, from Midwest Torah, a Judaic learning group in Indiana, says that after reading more about conversion therapy, he’s “not going to advise people to do it,” despite initially supporting the practice and signing the Declaration on the Torah Approach to Homosexuality.

 The former head of the APA Nicholas Cummings, who is led the fight to declassify homosexuality as a mental illness, has admitted gays can change!

(The New American)
For Avi, the Brandeis student, his “world shifted for the better” after coming out. He is currently looking to date other men, and is looking at the Jewish community, but not specifically the Orthodox one. aycha haysa kizonah

College is a time in which many gay young adults come out to their friends and family. For "Orthodox" LGBT teens, the decision to come out is even more difficult because of the "perceived taboos", and due to the fact that they generally live in their respective Jewish communities, where the attitudes toward gays is still unclearand this is the problem it should be very clear it's assur. For "frum" teens who identify as LGBT, there is a mix of hope and trepidation in their future paths. as the expression goes you can't dance at 2 chassunas, or as happened it says in milachim (18-23) ad masey atem poschiem al shitai hasifiem: how long will you dance between 2 opinions

Gidon Feen has just graduated from a yeshiva high school in Memphis, Tennessee. At a graduation party, he gets up in front of the kids he’s gone to school with for years. In mere seconds, after Gidon reveals that he is gay, the room erupts into applause.

Two years before he came out, Gidon “accepted” that he was gay. It took time to tell everyone, but Gidon says the reason for his coming out was due to the fact that “over the past two years, I just realized more and more this is who I am, this is me and I got sick of not being myself with my friends and people I interacted with. This is who I am and I want people to know that.”

According to some of the frum LGBT Jews I spoke to, there is worry about being able to attend shul and keep friends, and about how people will look at them when they walk down the hallways. There were also mentions of fears of physical harm against them and/or their friends and family. According to Gidon, however, the reception after his reveal “was unbelievably amazing, and beyond anything I would have imagined would happen.”

Gidon’s next stop is college—in the fall will attend The George Washington University (GWU) in Washington, DC, a school known for its political activism, as well as its significant Jewish and gay populations. Gidon is looking forward to college and “living an open gay lifestyle.” so they want as Rav Yoshe Ber Soloveichik said to sin and feel good about it He wishes to “stay "Jewish"” and date men. It hasn’t all been easy, however, and for years he experienced crises of faith whilst reconciling his identity. He is still searching for the answers to many more questions, such as how to have sex without committing a sin.notice he doesn't  look to abstain from having sex

In researching the article, many of those interviewed asked to remain anonymous due to possible repercussions. However, if the anecdotal evidence here is to be believed, though there are differences of opinion, there is a consensus of tolerance and support for LGBT Jews. Ben Schneider, an openly gay "Orthodox" graduate of the University of Pennsylvania, says that Orthodox Jews now recognize that “they have gay friends.” The conversation could go many ways from here, but it seems to be looking up for those who have lived in fear for a very long time.

There’s a phrase used by many different communities, which does describe the situation accurately: “It gets better.” only if your a sonei hashem
(momentmag)

Friday, August 2, 2013

"Orthodox" Gay Drag Queen

"orthodox" gay, "drag queen"

Gay "Orthodox" Jewish man one of Israel’s few "religious" drag queens 

Shahar Hadar, 34, is part of a growing cluster of devout-gay Jews in Israel. He is one of a few "religious" drag queens that perform on Israel's downtown circuit.


JERUSALEM — Just shy of midnight, Shahar Hadar trades his knitted white yarmulke for a wavy blond wig and a pink velvet dress.

Cheers greet him in a packed gay bar as he starts to swivel to a Hebrew pop song, his shiny red lips mouthing lyrics that mean more to him than the audience knows: "With God's help you'll have the strength / To overcome and give your all."

It has been a long and agonizing metamorphosis for Hadar, 34, from being a conflicted "Orthodox" Jew to a proud "religious" gay man - and drag queen. Most "Orthodox" Jewish gay men, like those in other conservative religious communities around the world, are compelled to make a devil's bargain: marry a woman to remain in their tight-knit religious community, or abandon their family, community and religion to live openly gay lives.



On Tisha Bav
But while Orthodox Judaism ?generally? condemns homosexuality, there is a growing group of devout-gay Jews in Israel unwilling to abandon their faith except those avrais that suit them and demanding a place in the religious community.

"As much as I fled it, the "heavens" made it clear to me that that's who I am," Hadar said. He is marching Thursday - out of costume - in Jerusalem's annual gay pride parade.

Hadar, a telemarketer by day, has taken the gay "Orthodox" struggle from the synagogue to the stage, beginning to perform as one of Israel's few "religious" drag queens. His drag persona is that of a rebbetzin, a female rabbinic advisor - a wholesome guise that stands out among the sarcastic and raunchy cast of characters on Israel's drag queen circuit.
 
"She blesses, she loves everyone," said Hadar of his alter-ego, Rebbetzin Malka Falsche. The stage name is a playful take on a Hebrew word meaning "queen" and Hebrew slang for "fake." Her philosophy, and Hadar's, draws from the teachings of the Breslov Hasidic except the parts that the biggest misnaged in the world agrees with stream of ultra-Orthodox Judaism: embrace life's vicissitudes with joy.

"Usually drag queens are gruff. I decided that I wanted to be happy, entertain people, perform aveiros mitzvoth," or religious deeds, he said.

An encounter with a popular Israeli rebbetzin is what launched Hadar's inner journey at age 19.
His Bigedai Isha


He began by wearing a yarmulke, a religious skullcap, and reciting morning prayers in his bedroom. He left home to enroll in a Jerusalem yeshiva, or religious seminary, hoping that daily Torah study would make him stop thinking about men.

It didn't.

After a brief nighttime encounter with his roommate at the yeshiva, Hadar said, he was booted from the seminary. He transferred to another religious studies center, where a student matched him up with his wife's ultra-Orthodox friend. They quickly married.

"I wanted to take the path that (God) commanded of us. I didn't see any other option," Hadar said. "I thought the marriage would make me straight and I would be cured."

He felt distressed while intimate with his wife, and wouldn't tell her why. She demanded a divorce. She later gave birth to their daughter, who is 11 years old today. His ex-wife still refuses to let them meet.

After Hadar's own sister met a similar fate - she divorced her husband because he was gay - "homophobic" conversation erupted around the Hadar family dinner table. Hadar's brother reprimanded the family, who had also become religious, by simply asking, "Are gays not human beings?" this is where the gay infiltration affects us.

His brother had stood up for Hadar without even knowing it.

A few months later, in 2010, Hadar mustered up the nerve to march in Tel Aviv's gay pride parade. When he returned home that Sabbath eve, he finally told his mother he was gay. "I thought it would be the blackest day in my life," Hadar said, but she accepted him.

As a practicing "Orthodox" Jew, it hasn't been easy for Hadar to integrate into mainstream gay life. He used to tuck his shoulder-length religious side locks under a cap to fit in at bars. Eventually, he sheared his side locks and trimmed his beard to thin stubble to increase his luck on the dating scene.

He's still looking for love. But this year, Hadar found acceptance - and self-expression - at Drag Yourself, a Tel Aviv school offering 10-month courses for budding drag performers. Students learn how to teeter on high heels, apply false eyelashes and fashion their own drag personas. Hadar, still a beginner, graduates next month.

The drag school, much like Israel's gay community itself, offers a rare opportunity for Israelis to interact with others from disparate and sometimes warring sectors of society. The school may be the only place where a Jewish settler, a lapsed ultra-Orthodox Jew, an Arab-Israeli and Israeli soldiers have stuffed their bras together.

Of all the students in his class, Hadar was the only one to show up wearing a yarmulke.

"I think it's fabulous," said Gil Naveh, a veteran Israeli drag queen and director of the school, as he painted Hadar's lips apple-red before his midnight debut at a Jerusalem gay bar. "He stays true to who he is."
(AP)highlights mine


Churban Yerushalayim 5773


As police helicopters monitored the parade from the sky, Police spokesman Micky Rosenfeld, who was helping oversee officers at the procession, said officers had taken extensive measures to ensure the safety of all participants at the march.
“Approximately 2,500 people are taking part in the parade and police have secured the area, and we’re escorting all the people taking part,” he said. “Special patrol units, border patrol units and undercover units are watching over the crowd.”

Despite the heavy police presence, Rosenfeld said three arrests were made at the parade by 8 p.m. – including of a haredi man who lobbed a stink bomb at marchers, and two women who dressed up as a donkey and monkey, carrying a sign that read “I’m a proud donkey,” to incite the crowd.

“Undercover officers and patrol units arrested them, and there were no injuries,” he said.

Rosenfeld added that police have also been monitoring several anti-gay demonstrations in the capital.
“At the same time we’re dealing with counter-demonstrations taking place in haredi neighborhoods, where there is a strong police presence,” he said.

Meanwhile, several participants at the event expressed their thoughts regarding acceptance and tolerance in a religious city, pluralism, personal safety and the differences between being gay in Jerusalem and Tel Aviv.

Chaya Grossman, 19, of Jerusalem – who was raised haredi and described herself as bisexual – said she found uncommon support from her ultra-Orthodox family.

“Maybe I’m not supposed to say it, but I feel quite safe because I have a loving family and loving friends,” said Grossman.

“But I also have friends who have been "abused" and "discriminated" against by their families and friends.”
Grossman said her family’s support surprised and encouraged her.

“My father said he knew [I was bisexual] when I first told him. But what makes it even more precious to me is that other haredi parents – and even secular parents – don’t accept their children for being gay.

“I’m fortunate,” she added.

Grossman conceded though that it has not been easy for her to be bisexual within her ultra- Orthodox community.

“Listen, I come from a haredi community, so I need to hide [my sexuality] from most of them,” she said.

In terms of comparing gay life in the capital to Tel Aviv – named the world’s best gay city in 2011 by LGBT travel website Gaycities.com – Grossman said Jerusalem is markedly less tolerant.

“I don’t really know the Tel Aviv gay community, but I know it’s much more open,” Grossman said. “Here people accept us less. We’re different.”

Guy Geron, 26, a computer science student from Tel Aviv, said he does not feel safe being gay in Jerusalem.

“I don’t feel safe here,” Geron said. “I don’t come here a lot, but my ex-boyfriend is from Jerusalem and I know I can’t act the same here as [in] Tel Aviv because here I can’t [publicly] express my affection for my boyfriend – or even speak out about things related to me being gay.

“You have to be smart here,” he added. “It’s not the way I like it, but I accept it as reality.”

Geron said he attributed Jerusalem’s lack of acceptance to the city’s “outspoken religious population.”

Asked what needed to be done to make Jerusalem more tolerant, he said the answer is twofold.
“I think it’s a matter of the politicians in office making changes, and gaining legitimacy from the people,” he said. “It’s a political process, as well as a social one.”

Meanwhile, David Shatz, 25, of Jerusalem and his girlfriend, Yael Sloma, 26, originally of Tel Aviv, said they attended the parade to support their gay friends.

“We came because we think it’s important – specifically in Jerusalem – to support gay rights because Jerusalem is a very conservative and religious city, even puritan,” said Shatz.

Sloma compared what she described as significant differences between gay life in Tel Aviv and Jerusalem.
“In Tel Aviv it’s like a huge party,” she said. “But here it’s more activist-related because it has much more significance, even though it should be a nonissue.

Of course, today it’s a major issue because of the parade.”

Sloma said she has noticed in the capital how rare it was for gay couples to be open in public.

“A few weeks ago, while I was walking down the street, I saw two girls holding hands, which in Tel Aviv is normal – but I realized how uncommon it is here,” she said.

Sloma attributed the dearth of openly gay citizens to the capital’s lack of “pluralism” and “liberalism.”

“I notice it even when I wear a short skirt,” she added.

Still, Tal, a journalist who requested her last name not be published, said she thinks conditions have improved for homosexuals in Jerusalem over the years.

“I pretty much feel accepted [in Jerusalem],” she said. “Lately, as the years pass, it has gotten more so than in previous years.

I’m not sure how it happened, but it’s how I feel.”

“I don’t feel safe, but that’s a general feeling because of the lack of peace,” she said. “It has nothing to do with being a lesbian.”
(Jerusalem Post)

Friday, May 24, 2013

"Orthodox Rabbi" Testified In Favor Of Rhode Island Legalizing Toevah Marriage





"Rabbi" Barry Dolinger of Congregation Beth Sholom in Providence said he believes that while civil law should allow gays and lesbians to marry, it must remain up to religious bodies to determine who can marry within their faith. Dolinger is also an attorney.
‘‘Never say never, but I will never perform a gay marriage as an orthodox rabbi because it’s prohibited by our main religious text,’’ he said. ‘‘But as a person of faith, it’s deeply important to me that the government stays far away from what we do. I’m all for letting people have it, and I think the government should stay out of preventing it, but we can’t compel people to violate their religious beliefs.’’
(Boston Globe)

Rabbi Dolinger was raised in North Bellmore, a small town on the South Shore of Long Island. He attended the University of Pennsylvania, where he majored in political science and minored in Ancient Near Eastern Studies. Afterwards, he spent a year studying at Yeshivat Netiv Aryeh in Israel. He received semichah from Yeshiva University in 2011, and graduated from Fordham Law School. Currently, he serves as the rabbi of Congregation Beth Sholom, an Orthodox community on the East Side of Providence, RI, where he lives with his wife, Naomi.
(Matzav)


Dolinger on bill to allow same gender "marriages"
  • I would not perform a same sex "marriage". In fact I would probably have my rabbinic title revoked from my school and my organization.  Nevertheless the less, I am here tonight in strong strong support of this bill.
 I think his suggestions in his introduction about what the YU and the RCA should do are very good.

  • But as a person of faith, it's deeply important to me that the government stays far away from what we do. I'm all for letting people have it, and I think the government should stay out of preventing it, but we can't compel people to violate their religious beliefs.
 I think he should read this story
  •  And I don’t want anybody telling me I’m going to do that, so I’m not going to tell anyone else that because I wouldn’t marry them that they can’t get married.”
why would someone argue for new "rights" that are against the God and his Torah for a group that wants to ban Bris Milah

Monday, May 6, 2013

"Orthodox" Lesbians", Still Think Gay "Marriage" Doesn't Influence Orthodox Jews?

Poster for the documentary DevOUT, about Orthodox lesbians in the New York-New Jersey area.
"orthodox" lesbian
Elissa Kaplan and Pamala Plastock live a life much like that of many Orthodox Jews, observing Shabbat, following kosher restrictions, keeping holiday traditions.

However, as lesbians, the Highland Park couple, who were legally "married" in Massachusetts in 2008, remain an anomaly in the "Orthodox" world.

The two women are among seven "Orthodox" lesbians from New York and New Jersey featured in the documentary DevOUT, which was screened March 13 by Rutgers Hillel at the George Street Student Activities Center in New Brunswick.

Speaking after the showing of the 37-minute film, Kaplan and Plastock said their local community seems more open-minded than some others in the observant world. While they do not belong to a synagogue, they are accepted at local Orthodox minyans, and Kaplan’s children from a former marriage have been welcomed at a local yeshiva, which they declined to name.

In fact, when the couple decided to hold a civil union ceremony a year and a half ago at Highland Park Borough Hall, Plastock said, they put out the word over an Internet listserv to community members, not knowing what response it would generate.

The end of the ceremony, which is included in the film, shows a room full of people — Rutgers Hillel associate director Rabbi Esther Reed among them — applauding as a judge wishes the couple a “mazel tov” on their union.

The number of people who turned out to celebrate with them “was just amazing,” said Plastock. “Our friends have remained steadfast.”

She said a reception followed at the Dunkin’ Donuts in Highland Park, which is under Orthodox kosher supervision.

While Kaplan acknowledged her community was wonderful, “in terms of religious leadership, it has been more of a process.”

The film, made by two students at Columbia University’s Graduate School of Journalism, shows other women caught between two worlds, at times estranged from their communities and seeking acceptance and family with each other.

The two young filmmakers are neither lesbian nor Jewish. Diana Neille is a Christian South African; Sana Gulzar is a Muslim from Pakistan. DevOUT has been shown in diverse locales, including last month at Pakistan’s largest film festival.

Kaplan said that her realization that she was a lesbian at first “felt like punishment,” while Plastock said, “I accept this is a sin. I accept Torah said it is wrong.”

However, Plastock said, like all religious Jews she is continually trying to improve her observance of the commandments and has chosen to focus her attention on other areas she can change.

“I believe God gave us the Torah,” said Plastock, adding that she also believes the specific passage condemning homosexuality had been “misinterpreted” by humans.
“I have to believe that,” she explained, “and if not, my hope is for a God who is forgiving.”

Kaplan said she didn’t envision “kiddushin,” the first phase of the marriage process under a huppa, being part of a same-sex ceremony because it is part of a traditional marriage ceremony as defined by Torah.

“Having a ketuba would also not be appropriate, but perhaps a different kind of contract,” she said. Acknowledging her apprehensions about coming out, Kaplan added, “I’ve been surprised every step of the way.”
(New Jersey News)

Thursday, April 11, 2013

"Orthodox Rabbi" Promotes Homosexuality And Kifera

"Rabbi" Hyim Shafner


When Hyim Shafner first started working as the campus rabbi for St. Louis Hillel at Washington University in the mid-1990s, he was approached by a male student with an unusual request.

“I’m having trouble meeting guys, rabbi,” Shafner remembers the student saying. “Can you fix me up with a nice Jewish boy?”

Suddenly Shafner’s days at the Orthodox Yeshiva University in New York “felt very far away,” he said.
But moments like that at the university got Shafner, now the rabbi at Bais Abraham Congregation in University City, to begin thinking more seriously about the special problems faced by homosexual "Orthodox" Jews.

“Jews are not a very big people,” he said. “I think of Judaism as a family, and it’s a shame someone has to leave Orthodoxy — their faith that they value — because they don’t feel like they can find a place in the family.”

As a way to introduce St. Louis’ Orthodox Jewish community to the lesbian, gay, bi-sexual and transgender — or LGBT — community, Bais Abraham and the Jewish Community Center of St. Louis will host a weekend of events April 12 to 14 designed to support Orthodox LGBT Jews.

The event was organized by Eshel, an organization that tries to create understanding for LGBT Jews in traditional Jewish communities. Eshel is bringing in three speakers to discuss what it’s like to be LGBT and Orthodox. The organization has held similar events in New York, Los Angeles and Washington, but next weekend’s event will be the first time it has brought a program like this to the Midwest.

“A lot of people are very curious about this topic,” said Aviva Buck-Yael, a member of Bais Abraham and an Eshel board member. “In most places, we have surprising turn outs. ... They want to know why people wish to stay in the Orthodox community when they’re LGBT. They want to find out how they make that work.”

Orthodox Judaism accepts homosexuals as members of the community as long as they are celibate. But, according to ?traditional? Orthodox rabbis, a sexually active member of the LGBT community would be acting in a way that’s inconsistent with traditional Orthodox practices, and could not properly call himself or herself an Orthodox Jew.

“It’s a hard thing, theologically, for people to deal with,” said Shafner. “But what if someone is born allergic to matzo — it’s the same thing theologically. God commanded them to eat matzo on Passover, but they can’t do it. ... Some Orthodox are driving to synagogue on Saturday, but you don’t find an uproar over that.”

Recent U.S. Supreme Court oral arguments about cases on the Defense of Marriage Act and California’s Proposition 8 have kept same-sex marriage in the news. And polls surrounding the issue continue to show a greater acceptance of same-sex marriage, especially among younger Americans — religious and not.

More than two-thirds of Americans say that gay and lesbian relationships should be accepted by society, while 26 percent disagree, according to a survey last month by the Public Religion Research Institute, or PRRI. But the survey found an even division over whether sex between two adults of the same gender is a sin — 44 percent say it is, 46 percent say it is not.

A Pew poll last month showed how dramatically attitudes have changed over gay issues, even over the last 10 years. In 2003, 58 percent of Americans were opposed to allowing gays and lesbians to marry legally, and 33 percent were in favor. Last month’s survey found that the trends have crossed, with 49 percent supporting same-sex marriage, and 44 percent opposed.

Jewish-Americans seem to be among the strongest supporters of gay issues. According to a PRRI survey last year, more than 80 percent of American Jews support allowing same-sex couples to marry legally, though the survey did not break down its results into Judaism’s different streams. About 1 percent of Missouri’s population in 2011 was Jewish, according to the North American Jewish Data Bank. And about 10 percent of St. Louis’ Jewish population is Orthodox.

Shafner said ?some? Orthodox Jews will inevitably be uncomfortable with next weekend’s programs, “but if people come and listen to the speakers tell their stories of staying with their faith against tremendous odds, they’ll be inspired.”

The Eshel events is on Friday night, with a dinner for LGBT Jews

On Saturday, Bais Abraham will host Shabbat services followed by a free lunch and a panel with the three speakers. On Saturday evening, Shafner will host a discussion — “Unity and Diversity in the Jewish Community: Can we have it all?” That will be followed by a screening of a short documentary, “DevOUT” featuring some of the women speaking on the panel.
 
(St. Louis Post-Dispatch)
Here is Shafners email address: please write a letter and tell him the Torah is not for sale.
rabbi@baisabe.com